Beating Hearts: Abortion and Animal Rights - download pdf or read online

By Sherry Colb, Michael Dorf

ISBN-10: 0231175140

ISBN-13: 9780231175142

ISBN-10: 0231540957

ISBN-13: 9780231540957

How can a person who condemns looking, animal farming, and animal experimentation additionally want felony abortion, that is the planned destruction of a human fetus? The authors of thrashing Hearts target to reconcile this obvious clash and think about the strangely related strategic and tactical questions confronted by means of activists within the pro-life and animal rights movements.

Beating Hearts continues that sentience, or the power to have subjective reports, grounds a being's entitlement to ethical hindrance. The authors argue that almost all human exploitation of animals is unjustified. Early abortions don't contradict the sentience precept simply because they precede fetal sentience, and Beating Hearts explains why the mere capability for sentience doesn't create ethical entitlements. past due abortions do elevate critical ethical questions, yet forcing a lady to hold a toddler to time period is complex as a kind of gender-based exploitation. those moral explorations bring about a much broader dialogue of the thoughts deployed by way of the pro-life and animal rights events. may still felony reforms precede or persist with attitudinal alterations? Do gory pictures win over or alienate supporters? Is violence ever principled? via probing the connections among debates approximately abortion and animal rights, Beating Hearts makes use of each one hugely contested set of inquiries to make clear the opposite.

Show description

Read or Download Beating Hearts: Abortion and Animal Rights PDF

Best human rights books

Hierarchy in International Law: The Place of Human Rights by Erika De Wet, Jure Vidmar PDF

This ebook takes an inductive method of the query of even if there's a hierarchy in overseas legislations, with human rights responsibilities trumping different tasks. It assesses the level to which one of these hierarchy could be stated to exist via an research of the case legislations of nationwide courts. each one bankruptcy of the ebook examines household case legislations on a topic the place human rights tasks clash with one other foreign legislations requirement, to work out even if nationwide courts gave priority to human rights.

New PDF release: The European Human Rights Culture: A Paradox of Human Rights

The ecu Human Rights tradition - A Paradox of Human Rights safeguard in Europe? analyses the political time period "European Human Rights Culture," a time period first brought through ecu fee President Barroso. situated within the fields of comparative legislations and eu legislation, this ebook analyses, via first-hand interviews with the ecu judiciary, the judicial point of view at the eu human rights tradition and units this in context to the political size of the time period.

Extra resources for Beating Hearts: Abortion and Animal Rights

Sample text

Choosing to refrain from attending dog fights therefore poses no threat to our well-being, but choosing to refrain from eating clearly would pose such a threat. The flaw in this analogy, however, is that it describes the two activities at two very different levels of generality. It describes dog fighting as either just dog fighting, which is the specific act at issue, or as frivolity or sadism, which are broad normative classifications. One could, however, more narrowly describe dog fighting as a form of cultural expression, as a manifestation of human skill, or as an important opportunity to gather with other people to socialize and connect, all of which sound like far more dignified and laudable sorts of engagements.

The moral force of the description of the partial-birth abortion that we quoted earlier arises from the sentience of the fetus. Yet the pro-life view typically emphasizes something quite different: the humanity of the fetus. ”20 Prolife doctors, politicians, and advocates frequently say that scientific evidence proves that conception—the fusion of human sperm and human egg—marks the beginning of each new human life. 24 ETHICS In some versions of the argument, the assembly of twenty-three chromosome pairs marks the beginning of a unique human life.

But Rawls remains broadly influential, and even those, Sentience or Species? 35 like Nussbaum, who part company with Rawls on some matters do not deny that human beings have moral duties to the most disadvantaged in virtue of their disadvantage. In other words, incapacity, not just capacity, can give rise to moral entitlements. But that brings us to the question: Does the widely shared intuition that it is at least permissible and probably laudable to provide affirmative aid to the needy among us entail the proposition that we must provide aid to needy nonhuman animals as well?

Download PDF sample

Beating Hearts: Abortion and Animal Rights by Sherry Colb, Michael Dorf


by Jeff
4.3

Rated 4.83 of 5 – based on 28 votes